As the festive season is well underway, our ears are once again filled with the familiar tunes of “Carol of Bells,” “Silent Night,” and “Deck the Halls.” While these classic catchy Christmas songs have rightfully earned their place in the holiday canon, there exists a treasure trove of lesser-known hidden gems that often go unnoticed. Here we unwrap some of the most underrated Christmas carols and songs that deserve a spot on your holiday playlist.

“In the Bleak Midwinter” by Christina Rossetti:

Inspired by Christina Rossetti’s poignant poem, “In the Bleak Midwinter” has been set to music by various composers over the years. Its hauntingly beautiful melody and introspective lyrics capture the quieter, reflective side of Christmas. This carol invites listeners to embrace the simplicity and serenity of the season.

“The Christmas Waltz” by Frank Sinatra:

While Frank Sinatra is a household name, “The Christmas Waltz” is often overshadowed by his more popular holiday hits. This timeless tune, with its graceful melody and Sinatra’s smooth vocals, adds a touch of elegance to your Christmas celebrations. It’s a perfect choice for a heartfelt slow dance by the fireplace.

“The Holly and the Ivy” – Traditional:

Originating from England, “The Holly and the Ivy” is a traditional carol that paints a vivid picture of nature’s role in the Christmas story. Its lyrics use symbolism to tell the tale of the holly and the ivy, connecting these natural elements to the birth of Jesus. The simplicity and charm of this carol make it a hidden gem in the isle of England

“We Need a Little Christmas” by Jerry Herman:

While not entirely unknown, “We Need a Little Christmas” from the 1955 musical “Mame” often takes a backseat to other festive tunes. This lively and uplifting song is a burst of holiday cheer, reminding us that sometimes a little Christmas spirit is all we need to brighten our days.

“Some Children See Him” by Alfred Burt and Wihla Hutson:

Dive into the multicultural side of Christmas with “Some Children See Him.” This carol, composed by Alfred Burt with lyrics by Wihla Hutson, celebrates the diversity of how children around the world perceive primarily Jesus as a child. Its message of inclusivity and acceptance is a beautiful addition to any Christmas playlist.

“What Are You Doing New Year’s Eve?” by Frank Loesser:

While not a traditional Christmas song, “What Are You Doing New Year’s Eve?” often gets overlooked in the holiday lineup. Frank Loesser’s poignant lyrics and the soulful melodies create a sense of anticipation and reflection that perfectly captures the transition from one year to the next. This tune adds a touch of sophistication to your holiday playlist and serves as a reminder to cherish the moments leading up to the new year.

“The Friendly Beasts” – Traditional:

Originating from medieval France, “The Friendly Beasts” is a charming carol that tells the story of the animals present at the birth of Jesus. Each animal, from the donkey to the cow, offers a special gift to the newborn child. The simplicity of the melody and the endearing narrative make this carol a delightful addition to any Christmas gathering.

“It’s in Every One of Us” by David Pomeranz:

While not exclusively a Christmas song, “It’s in Every One of Us” carries a universal message of love and goodwill that aligns with the spirit of the season. Featured in the movie “Big,” this song encourages us to recognize the inherent goodness in every person, making it a unique and uplifting choice for the holiday season.

“Christmas Time Is Here” by Vince Guaraldi Trio:

Known for its association with the beloved animated classic, “A Charlie Brown Christmas,” “Christmas Time Is Here” by the Vince Guaraldi Trio often flies under the radar compared to other holiday classics. The gentle piano melody and soothing vocals capture the nostalgic and contemplative atmosphere of the season, making it a perfect backdrop for quiet moments of reflection.

“All I Want for Christmas is You” by Vince Vance & The Valiants:

No, this is not Mariah Carey’s megahit. Vince Vance & The Valiants released their own version of “All I Want for Christmas is You” in 1989, basically a cover. It’s a hidden gem that deserves attention. This country-tinged ballad expresses the sentiment of wanting love and togetherness for Christmas, showcasing a different musical style that adds variety to your holiday playlist.

Maybe Next Year Put an Underrated Christmas Carols

As you curate your Christmas playlist this year, don’t forget to explore the lesser-known treasures that add depth and diversity to the festive atmosphere. Whether you’re drawn to the historical charm of traditional carols, Christ-themed church musicals or the contemporary flair of overlooked classics, these underrated Christmas songs offer a refreshing alternative to the usual holiday tunes. So, embrace the joy of musical exploration, and let these hidden gems be the soundtrack to your festive season. After all, the magic of Christmas lies in the discovery of new melodies that resonate with the spirit of the season.

I’m partial to Good King Wenceslas myself!